Permalink
My wife attends a Liberal Arts college set in the middle of a religious city in a very, very red state. As such, she attends school with many extreme feminists, green party members, hipsters, pseudo-intellectuals… basically, fake Liberals. This is to be expected. I can’t fault them for ending up the way they did because I absolutely understand. In a religious stronghold like Salt Lake City you can’t just go mildly Left if you’re going to go Left at all. At least, you can’t start that way. In the beginning, you have to make that initial Left turn a really fucking hard one to have any impact or make any sort of impression upon your tried and true red state neighbors.
I would know. See, I was born in this pitiful valley in the very religion that dominates the entire state. I moved around a lot as a child, but seemed to always end up in the most conservative areas you could think of. Even in the traditionally Liberal parts of the country I happened to live, I always found myself occupying the one damn town or city that had a conservative edge. Eventually, I ended up back in Utah for about 5 years, this time in the South, living in a smallish city called St. George. Even more ultraconservative and Mormon than Salt Lake City has been in a very long time. More comparable to Provo or the small townships that dot mid-Utah all the way up to and including American Fork. Any Utahans that happen to read this will know exactly what I’m talking about.
Digression aside, the point is that I also made the hard Left turn when I was a younger man. At around 14, actually. So yes, I do understand. However, where I lack understanding is in the lateness of age that a lot of these classmates of hers are making that turn. The age of 14 seems reasonable. Then you start to grow up. You keep your politics, your theological opinions, your Liberal way of thinking; but you evolve all of it, you sophisticate your ideas and you cease the fiery, but ultimately pointless rebellion. Rebellion itself is not necessarily a harmful thing, but that blaze that comes with an initial formulation of opinion and belief that comes with the Left turn I’ve mentioned so many times is a harmful and useless thing. Thus, the necessity for sophistication.
Now, I bring this up not only to express my disbelief in people in their 20’s and beyond behaving the way I did at 14, but also to make a point on the subject of Liberalism itself. Because this problem doesn’t exist solely in the realm of the Lefty late bloomers brought up in religious strongholds. No, this problem has roots everywhere. And most recently, it has been seen displaying itself on the streets of cities across this country.
Personally, I consider myself to be a pretty Liberal thinker in most aspects. There are a few on which I’ve been known to take a more classical conservative approach (the death penalty for one, war for another), but in general I usually find myself thinking like a love child conceived by Christopher Hitchens, Karl Marx, Bernie Sanders and Bill Maher. Even so, I have not agreed with the stance of my wife’s classmates and others like them about pretty much anything since I was 16 years old. They are naïve to the point of being almost laughable. Go ahead, head down to the local hipster hangout in your city and ask them who they want for president (if anyone) and why. Go, ask the questions and witness the infestation for yourself.
Liberalism has found itself taken hostage by spinelessness and irrationalists. Those are the two sides to the hideous coin that has become the public face of the modern Left leaning political and social spectrum. We have the spineless mainline Liberals like those in Congress who are too afraid of stepping on any toes to actually doing anything that could be considered remotely progressive. And then we have the irrationalists, who are so quick to champion any bullshit cause that can be considered “Liberal” that they have turned our side into a complete mockery in the eyes of the Right. So now you understand why I so casually referred to them as “fake” at the beginning of this entry. The fundamental lack of understanding concerning the history and true meaning behind any one of their pet causes is what makes them so dangerous and stupid. Their entire reason for being seems only to be blind anger towards an enemy they can’t even define. Demonization of this enemy is their only weapon, but a lack of understanding about said enemy leads only to wild invention of its supposed crimes while the true danger of whatever is being discussed is ignored.
-Occupiers across the country screaming at the 1% without taking the time to learn a fucking thing about tax brackets, stock trading, hedge funds, the free market or anyfuckingthing else that caused the problems they’re so upset about.
-Extreme feminists everywhere villainizing all men everywhere while also showing a disturbing obsession with phallic symbols; never stopping to question or understand the nature of oppression or even contemplate the idea that a great deal of men are not the horrible opportunistic rapists we’re all made out to be.
-Ron Paul supporters claiming to be Liberals up and down this country showing a complete lack of knowledge about any of his policies or even realizing that he’s a Republican candidate. Yes, yes, he’s the Godfather of Libertarianism. But guess what? Libertarianism is a sect of Conservatism. Look at the little letter in parenthesis that precedes Paul’s name next time you see him on CNN, that’ll tell you all you need to know.
It goes on and on. As much distaste as I have for the spineless Democrats and Left leaning independents in Congress, I find the irrationalists to be far more dangerous. They are, essentially, the Tea Party of the Left. The basic principles are all there, buried somewhere at the bottom of ideology, but they’ve gotten skewed and distorted in the fog of anti-reason and blind rage. Don’t get me wrong. I’m just as passionate about all of the same issues. The economy, foreign policy, social justice, equal rights. The difference is, my stance on these subjects is not simply determined by going as far opposite as the over-elevated “devil” of an enemy as I possibly can. The difference is, I’ve given actual thought to the issues before forming an opinion. And so have many of my fellow Lefties.
That’s the difference. That’s what makes them fake, and us real. We attempt to see the issues for what they are: Complex. We avoid the arrogant black and white certitude of our fake peers by learning and trying to understand the subtleties of every issue that holds any importance to us. When I look at the members of the Occupy Movement, I don’t see rational people elevating the intellectual level of public discourse, I see a step backwards. When I listen to ignorant Liberal Arts students yelling about racial oppression and the need for marijuana legality, I don’t hear a person making reasoned and well-thought out arguments, I hear a blithering idiot who has done literally no research on the subject of his/her anger. I see and hear hijackers. Nothing more. Dimwitted embarrassments for our side that are retarding the progressive movement of this and every other nation out there.
So yes, when I was 15 years old and trapped in Southern Utah and a devoutly religious family, I was like them. I yelled and stomped and clawed and scratched just like them. But then I decided to get a grip and cool my jets. I decided to actually read and study and fucking learn about these subjects I was yelling so loudly about. I found myself wholeheartedly disagreeing with so many things I had been sure were the pure truth just months and years ago. I found myself turning into a much different, but wholly better person. And in the end, I found myself more purely defined as a Liberal than I had been before.
In the case of my wife’s peers, all in their 20’s or beyond, living in the religious center that is Utah and age are no longer excuses they can make without sounding absolutely childish. For everyone else, the same holds true. The excuses you can make for the behavior of your 15 year old self are no longer good enough. The time has come to grow up and, as I said before, evolve and sophisticate your way of thinking. Left or Right, what matters most is how the opinions and ideas were formed. If you came to your conclusions by research and study; by genuine and honest thought and discussion; then you did it right. If, however, you came to those conclusions through ignorance, useless prayer, blind aggression, determined contrarianism, selfishness, greed, some or all of the above…well, then you’re either one of the hated irrationalist fake liberals I’ve spent so much time talking about. Or you’re a Conservative.
Either way.